⛩️

Session 2 - The Buddha’s Fist

Review of Session One

The Buddha asks Ānanda where his mind is. Ānanda replies with seven possible locations:

  1. Pervasively throughout the entire body
  2. Pervasively outside the body
  3. ‘Hidden’ inside the sense organ/faculty
  4. Inside the sense organ, but only being able see out through an orifice (i.e. the pupil)
  5. Arising within the sense organ when the conditions are present
  6. Neither internal nor external, but in a middle location
  7. Without location for being that which does not cling

PART ONE: ‘Transient Dust’

In this section the Buddha uses the opening and closing of his fingers, making a fist, as an upāya to introduce the ‘original bright wonderous essential’ Mind, as opposed to the false conception of a subjective mind.

First - the buddha shows his fist and tells Ānanda, the mind that sees the fist is not really his Mind.

Second - the Buddha explains that ‘seeing’ complete darkness is not not seeing.

Third - Ājñāta-kāuṇḍinya explains ‘transient dust’ as that which moves (i.e. is impermanent).

Fourth - the Buddha shoots light rays at Ānanda and asks, “What moves?”

This session covers:

Hsuan Hua translation, p. 29-47 of the book (p.85-103 of the pdf)

Luk translation, p. 11-24 of the book (p.25- of the pdf)

Goddard translation, p. 123-131 of the book